CO129-585-7 Sino-Japanese conflict- interned Chinese soldiers 18-1-1940 - 27-12-1940 — Page 28

28

HELD: Re question of which blow caused the spleen to rupture

that is a question for jury.

quali

Re- evidence of blow. Was it unlawful? Not question in kind and quantity than was necessary for defendant to defend himself and applying test of Lindly J. in R. v. Knock 14 Cox. 12, I hold that defendant has no case to answer.

sd) Eric Himsworth, P.M.K.,

CERTIFIED

TRUE

COPY

Ahlos

Magistrate's Clerk, Kowloon,

May, 1940.

16/440.